Crumbl’s 2026 Easter lineup is officially hopping into stores. Carrot Cake, Dubai Nest Dirt Cake Cup, Easter Pink Sugar, Spring M&M’s, and Strawberries ‘N Cream, cookies make up this line up. Let’s give them a try!
According to the description on Crumbl’s web site, the Carrot Cake cookie includes, “Two layers of carrot cake mixed with warm spices, coconut, pineapple, and carrots, complete with a light glaze and vanilla cream cheese frosting, and topped with chopped pecans.” We found that this one was not the best. Crumbl has had better. Our expectations were too high for this cake, because their previous lineups were really good. When we first bit into the Carrot Cake, we looked at each other with expressions of confusion. The texture is spongy, and the taste is carrots with cinnamon. There are chunks of the pineapple, coconut, and carrot which don’t really compliment the cake the way it should. The coconut and pineapple make the texture different, which is cool but doesn’t work out in the best way. We knew right away that this one wasn’t going to be the best, so we decided to try it first to get it out of the way, and it turns out we were right.
Crumbl’s Dubai Nest Dirt Cake is described as “Layers of silky chocolate mousse, crunchy cookies and cream streusel, and gummy worms, topped with Dubai Chocolate-inspired pistachio crème, crisp Katifi, and chocolate candy eggs.” When we read the description, we predicted that this was going to be the best one, but surprisingly it wasn’t. We had thought there was going to be more Dubai Chocolate than there was, so we were disappointed about that, but the Dubai Chocolate tasted really good. It is the best part! The flavor of the mousse is a little watered down, but tasty, and the Oreo chunks are flavorful and improve the dirt cake. With more Dubai Chocolate, and if the mousse wasn’t so watered down, this would have definitely been one of the best from the lineup.
The Easter Sugar Cookie consists of “classic almond sugar cookie topped with a silky pink and yellow marbling of real almond frosting.” We both thought this is the second best of the lineup. It tastes like their regular sugar cookies, which is a positive. The texture is soft, and all the flavors compliments each other very well. It is super sweet but in a good way. We were glad that this was a good flavor because we both like sugar cookies. They did a great job on this one.
The Spring M&M’S Cookie has “a timeless cookie bursting with colorful, spring-inspired M&M’S Candies.” This was single-handedly the best cookie. Once again, it tastes like their regular M&M’s Cookie, just made with Easter pastel-colored M&M’s. This cookie is the perfect amount of sweetness, and it is warm, and the flavors melt in your mouth. It was delicious. The texture was a little crumbly when we bit into it, but it was still so good.
The Strawberries ‘N Cream Cookie is made with “a vanilla cake cookie with fresh house-made whipped cream, strawberry jam, and strawberry slices.” This is the third best cookie among those we tasted. It isn’t the best but is not the worst. It was too crumbly when we picked it up and just fell apart. The cookie isn’t sweet enough and is a little dry, making it hard to swallow, and the strawberries in the cookie we tried were mushy. If they improved these aspects, this the cookie could have been the best one!
Overall, we found these treats were not worth the money. We spent over $30 for a six pack of cookies that were not the best we’ve had. The cookies were overpriced, which wouldn’t be so upsetting if they had tasted better than they did. Crumbl usually has better cookies, so hopefully next year Crumbl Cookie will come back with a better Spring lineup.
